Metaphysics

Continuants: Their Activity, Their Being, and Their Identity by David Wiggins

By David Wiggins

This quantity gathers twelve essays by means of David Wiggins in a space the place his paintings has been relatively influential. one of the matters taken care of are: endurance of a substance via switch, the proposal of a continuant, the good judgment of identification, the co-occupation of house by way of a continuant and its topic, the relation of individual to human organism, the metaphysical concept of an individual, the prestige of artefacts, the relation of the three-d and 4-dimensional conceptions of fact, and the nomological underpinning of sortal class. From a miles greater physique of labor the writer has chosen, edited or annotated, and variously shortened or prolonged 11 items. He has additional an creation and one thoroughly new essay, at the philosophy of biology and the position there of the assumption of strategy. the gathering starts off with an essay postdating his Sameness and Substance Renewed (2001), which amends and upstages his prior presentation of his sortalist belief of id. In next essays and the advent Wiggins examines the contributions to those topics made via Heraclitus, Aristotle, Leibniz, Roderick Chisholm, Hilary Putnam, Sydney Shoemaker, Michael Ayers, Saul Kripke, W. V. Quine, David Lewis, Fei Xu, and others.

Show description

Read Online or Download Continuants: Their Activity, Their Being, and Their Identity PDF

Best metaphysics books

Nietzsche, Volumes 3-4

A landmark dialogue among nice thinkers--the moment (combining volumes III and IV) of 2 volumes inquiring into the imperative problems with Friedrich Nietzsche's philosophy.

Philosophical Mysteries

Publication via Ross, Stephen David

Ontological Categories

The idea that of an ontological classification is principal to metaphysics. Metaphysicians argue approximately which classification of lifestyles an item will be assigned to, even if one class could be decreased to a different one, or even if there can be assorted both enough platforms of categorization. solutions to those questions presuppose a transparent realizing of what accurately an ontological class is, and Jan Westerhoff now presents the 1st in-depth research.

Berkeley's Argument for Idealism

Samuel C. Rickless offers a unique interpretation of the concept of George Berkeley. In A Treatise about the rules of Human wisdom (1710) and 3 Dialogues among Hylas and Philonous (1713), Berkeley argues for the stunning view that actual items (such as tables and chairs) are not anything yet collections of principles (idealism); that there's no such factor as fabric substance (immaterialism); that summary principles are very unlikely (anti-abstractionism); and that an concept could be like not anything yet an idea (the likeness principle).

Extra info for Continuants: Their Activity, Their Being, and Their Identity

Example text

Is that good enough? It may be objected that I have long since committed our enquiry to the matter-of-factual-cum-metaphysical absoluteness and determinacy of identity (cf. section 3, at the end and section 4, notes 8, 9, and 12), yet admitted also that our conceptions of substances, artefacts, and almost every other kind of thing are incompletely determinate. I reply that this difficulty, if it is a difficulty, is not peculiar to artefacts. Nor is it a problem. It is often pointed out in a similar cause that our thoughts about mountains leave massive indeterminacy about their exact extent.

I reply by reverting to Leibniz’s distinction between clear (workable/operationally applicable) ideas or conceptions of a thing-kind and more distinct (more analytical or scientifically and otherwise spelled out) ideas or conceptions. In this connection Leibniz would point out that, if we did not bring to experience something not itself of experience, we should be unable to make anything of experience. Innate within us there has to be not only an eagerness to look for continuities and a willingness to associate one presentation with some earlier presentation, but a predisposition also to search out certain particular kinds of thing.

It is a sort of universal. 10 Until we reached the question of a sufficient condition, the logic of identity seemed simple and austere. The ragged or discursive character of everything that I have been claiming since we began upon the question of sufficiency has none of that simplicity or austerity. So it needs to be shown how the sortal conception of identity can satisfy the formal requirements we began with. Let us begin here with the best case, namely where we have a natural kind whose members, the gs, share in a phusis which brings with it an empirically discoverable real principle of activity or nature which underlies and undergirds— in ways that Putnam and Kripke (and in his own way Leibniz) have each described—the application of certain ordinary substantives or sortal predicates.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.06 of 5 – based on 34 votes